Epic Romances - Books Review

I had heard a lot about Ashok Banker and was indeed excited when his books on Mahabharata were up for review. What also excited me was the interesting positioning of the books. They were positioned as the ‘Epic Love story collection’. By no means can I be considered to have even a remotely romantic disposition. But keeping with the demands of Indian publishers, I have been trying my hand at writing romance these days. So I was keen on seeing how an acknowledged master of fiction writing has handled this genre; that too mixed with my favorite genre of mythology.

To start with, I must say the concept is excellent. The publishers have done an excellent job with the presentation. The books look really attractive in their fascinating glossy covers with beautiful cover illustrations. The small size of the books gives them a cute look making them an excellent option for romantic gift. The other advantage of the size is that the books can be easily carried around and can be finished in a single long bus ride to office. The author has kept the language and narrative also very simple. It is a very easy read and does not tax the mind of the reader too much. So it is an ideal read when one is tired from the day's work.

The stories as such are nothing new for someone familiar with Mahabharata. But probably most of the current crop of youth would have missed Rajagopalachari’s Mahabharata, the Amar Chitra Katha mythological comics and BR Chopra’s Mahabharata serial as well. For them, these books would be an excellent opportunity to get familiar with one of the world’s most ancient and greatest epics. For me personally though the books did not hold that much charm. I have been told these stories in great detail by my grandfather in my very early childhood. Then as I grew up, I read the comics and saw the serial on TV serial as well. So the books felt more like a rerun.

I have read different foreign authors’ rendering of the same Arthurian legends. So I expected something of a similar nature in Ashok Banker’s books. At least the two books I picked for review – ‘Satyavati and Shantanu’ and ‘Amba and Bishma’ however had hardly any novelty factor. There were hardly any new elements or unique interpretations to the already known stories. It was just the basic old story narrated as it is with details filled in. I must say the author has done a commendable job filling in the details though. I especially liked the description of the war scene in the ‘Amba and Bishma’ story. I would actually rate these books a good read in themselves for someone who does not know the Mahabharata stories. But given that it is an existing plot and not originally conceived by the author, I hardly see any strong stamp of the author in the stories. That in some ways can be viewed positively as well. Some readers may like to enjoy the purity of the original stories without them being twisted by the author’s own interpretations and improvisations.

So I would call these books a plain and simple retelling of the original stories from Mahabharata as tales of romance and adventure, leaving out the more philosophical and esoteric elements to make them more palatable for the casual reader.

This review is a part of the biggest Book Review Program for Indian Bloggers. Participate now to get free books!


Tall Girl in Japan said...

I loved reading Ashok Banker's Ramayana series. There is a lot of Drama and unique interpretation in them. But I suppose he really didn't have so much of a scope with short stories !

T F Carthick said...

I haven't yet tried the Ramayana series. Maybe I should try them then.

DS said...

Seems to be a good read for those who have not read anything on Mahabharata. I have seen the serial and the stories were told to me by my grandfather too just as in your case.

T F Carthick said...

Thats right, DS. As the previous commentor pointed out, the other books may be better. Even among the two books I read the Bishma story seemed far better than the Shantanu story.

debajyoti said...

even though i don't read books but i don't think i would have read it anyway. the new generation may not be aware of these stories but i am sure, people of my age know each and everything in detail about Mahabharata.

Purba said...

I have yet to read Ashok Banker's version but of all the modern interpretations I have read, Devdutt's Pattanaik's Jaya remains my favourite.

T F Carthick said...

Same with be debajyothi. Though some weird interpretation would have been fun to read.

T F Carthick said...

I have heard of the one you mention, Purba. If you recommend it probably I will give it a try. I have read Devdutt's blog and another book of his - It was quite logical and interesting.

Post a Comment

Kind words of appreciation/feedback

For whom the bell tolls

A book of faces